Tesshin began by noting that it was worthwhile to spend more time exploring the teachings of the Sixth Patriarch, Huineng. When considering the foundational sutras of Zen—aside from the Shurangama and various other teachings and chants—the three texts technically called sutras are the Heart Sutra, the Diamond Sutra, and the Platform Sutra, which contains Huineng’s teachings. During the period of the Sixth Patriarch, Zen teachings matured in a way that begins to sound distinctly like Zen as it is recognized today, compared to earlier texts.
Turning back to Huineng’s story for a deeper look, Tesshin recalled that Huineng originally worked in forestry, chopping wood for the market. By the time he arrived at Hongren’s temple, he was there not as a monk, but as a laborer practicing Zen. While the story of Huineng sifting rice, having his exchange with Hongren, and being sent to work is familiar, Tesshin wanted to examine more closely what happened during that period.
In the temple Hongren had built with his teacher, Doshin, there was a wall bearing old, deteriorating paintings of ancient Buddhist figures and stories. Recognizing that the wall needed to be repaired and painted over, Hongren gathered the large community of monks together. At that time, Huineng was just a worker, while Shenxiu was the head monk—the most senior and highly advanced practitioner under Hongren. Hongren told the monks that before they painted over the wall, he wanted them all to write a gatha, or poem, expressing their deepest understanding of practice. He announced that whichever poem demonstrated the deepest understanding of the teachings would determine the next abbot, designating that person as his successor to take over when Hongren eventually stepped down.
Shenxiu reasoned that as the head priest who had trained there for a long time, the other monks would likely hold back out of deference and humility until he wrote something. Feeling an obligation as their leader to open the door for them, he decided he would write the first poem. However, he was soon struck by doubt, questioning whether he was writing to win the position of abbot or genuinely to express his understanding of the Dharma. Shenxiu’s practice was deeply contemplative, centered on examining one’s life, mind, and motivations. Despite his deep practice and understanding of the Dharma, he could not easily commit, going back and forth over whether he was driven by personal desire or by a wish to be of service to the other monks.
Tesshin noted that this illustrates an important truth: every monk and practitioner is different and walks their own path. Some practitioners are deeply contemplative, continually examining things with a questioning mind, and that is a valid path. Others follow a different path. Eventually, Shenxiu resolved to write something, composing some words of Dharma and concluding with a gatha.
Without reading the accompanying commentary, Tesshin shared Shenxiu’s poem:
The body is the Bodhi tree.
The mind is like a bright mirror’s stand.
At all times we must strive to polish it
and must not let the dust collect.
This verse reflects diligence, continuous practice, refinement, and deep examination in order to reach the essence of one’s being.
When Hongren walked by the next day and saw the poem, he praised it highly. Although it was unsigned, he figured out who had written it, and he instructed all the monks to learn and recite it, treating it as a pinnacle of practice. Soon, all the monks were chanting the verse as a way to embody it.
Shortly afterward, one of the monks walked past the kitchen area chanting the poem while Huineng was polishing rice. Hearing the verse, Huineng felt it did not strike right. Because he was illiterate, he asked another monk to take him to see it written and read the text aloud so he might understand it better. After hearing both the commentary and the poem, Huineng remained unconvinced and asked the literate monk to write a poem of his own on the wall—a bold request, given that Huineng was not even an ordained monk, only a worker in deep practice. The monk agreed, took a writing utensil, and wrote down Huineng’s response:
Bodhi originally has no tree.
The bright mirror also has no stand.
Fundamentally there is not a single thing.
Where could any dust alight?
With that, Huineng simply returned to work.
Tesshin contrasted these two completely different approaches to the Dharma and practice. Shenxiu was deeply contemplative, constantly examining the mind in meditation. Huineng, on the other hand, was illiterate and had only ever known the direct relationship between himself and the object in front of him. Growing up, his relationship to the universe consisted simply of himself, an axe, and a tree—chopping it down. When he later heard the Diamond Sutra, it resonated deeply because of that direct experience; he was not an academic and did not overthink things. When he came to the temple, there was simply the rice, the sifter, and himself, so he got to work. There was no analyzing or contemplation—it was straightforward, simple, and free of doubt. That was the spirit in which he wrote his poem.
When Hongren walked by the next day and saw the new verse, he asked who had written it, though he suspected he knew the answer. Publicly, he told everyone to forget it and paint over the wall. That evening, however, Hongren summoned Huineng to his room and told him that his understanding of the Dharma matched Hongren’s own, naming Huineng his successor. Hongren then handed over his bowl and robes and instructed Huineng to leave immediately, explaining that for political and social reasons, it was not safe for him to stay at the temple.
Tesshin emphasized that this outcome should not be interpreted to mean that Huineng’s Zen teaching was superior while Shenxiu’s was inferior. Shenxiu was a great Zen master—one of the best. At that time in China, the division between the north and the south was dominant, a tension that appears frequently in Zen stories of the era. Tesshin observed that strong prejudice or contention typically develops between groups that share a long, complex history with one another, similar to cultural divides seen elsewhere, such as between the north and south in the United States. Because of these regional divisions in China, Shenxiu went on after Hongren to lead the northern school of Zen, which had a vital, robust liturgy and powerful teachings, while Huineng became the head of the southern school. Reading both poems, both make complete sense and both are right; there can be more than one truth or reality. It was not a matter of one being right and the other wrong, though Huineng’s expression was deeper, more direct, and without doubt.
Tesshin pointed out that this is also an important lesson because practitioners will meet all kinds of teachers, monks, and fellow students. Some have a great deal of thinking and analysis going on, which is a path to the Dharma. Others are absolute, which is also a path. Whatever a person’s path may be, the task is simply to follow it.
Turning to the ritual significance of the story, Tesshin explained that the text is called the Platform Sutra after the platform where services and ceremonies take place, which forms the basis of many rituals, including ordination. The act of handing over a bowl and a robe was ordination itself: at that moment, Huineng was ordained as successor and sent away in the dark. For a long period afterward, ordination remained a private event held at midnight rather than a large public ceremony, and the newly ordained person would often leave afterward.
Tesshin reflected on how ceremonies change over time, comparing this to the original wedding ceremony described in the Old Testament. In the very beginning, the bride and groom simply went to the top of a mountain under a full moon, betrothed themselves to each other, and consummated the betrothal—and that was getting married. Compared to modern weddings with guests, flowers, catering, and bands, the ceremony could not look more different, even though all of those extras are beside the point; at its core, marriage is simply about those two people. In the same way, ordination at its core is about a teacher, a student, and that connection.
Tesshin noted that for years he had told members of the sangha that none of them were his students and he was not their teacher, encouraging everyone to find wisdom and practice wherever they could. However, ordination marks the first time a solid connection is established between a teacher and a student, involving commitment and transmission. Unlike jukai—taking on the precepts, which is a joyous, celebratory occasion—shukke tokudo (shukke meaning to leave one’s household and give up worldly things, and tokudo meaning to take on the way) sets aside much of the ceremonial embellishment. There are no fancy implements like whisks or fans, no brocaded robes, and no poems; participants dress simply. While the underlying structure—taking vows, exchanging commitments, and giving and putting on the robes—is similar, it is much more straightforward. All of it originates from that exchange between Hongren and Huineng, which marks the birth of the ordination process.
Tesshin concluded by noting that the sangha would continue studying the Platform Sutra and its teachings, including why the robe and bowl in particular were used. He underscored how fascinating this story is, both as the origin of the ordination ceremony and as a reminder not to treat one teaching as better than another, as both are powerful. In reading these verses, one begins to hear the distinct voice of Zen—moving beyond broad Buddhist concepts into a refined, cherished tradition.

Leave a Reply